Cashless Society 無現金社會理想嗎?

印度總理莫迪為了打擊貪污及洗錢,上月無預警地宣布停用 500 及 1000 盧比紙幣(約 235 和 471 台幣),引發軒然大波。11 月底,莫迪進一步宣示,將致力推動印度朝無現金社會前進。專家普遍認為,無現金社會雖然理想,但是印度要做無現金社會,就不太理想了。
Photo credit: 世界公民文化中心提供。
Photo credit: 世界公民文化中心提供。

本文由 世界公民文化中 心提供,INSIDE 獲授權刊登。更多資訊請見 世界公民文化中心粉絲專頁

印度總理莫迪為了打擊貪污及洗錢,上月無預警地 宣布停用 500 及 1000 盧比紙幣(約 235 和 471 台幣),引發軒然大波。11 月底,莫迪進一步宣示,將致力推動印度朝無現金社會前進。專家普遍認為,無現金社會雖然理想,但是印度要做無現金社會,就不太理想了。


"Our dream is that there should be a cashless society. This is correct that a 100% cashless society is never possible. But we can start with a less-cash society --- then cashless society will not be a far-off destination," Modi said in his monthly ‘Mann Ki Baat' address, appealing to youth to teach 10 families daily on how they could do cashless transactions through mobile apps, mobile banking and debit/credit cards. –The Economic Times

The Economic Times 報導,印度總理莫迪在每月例行的全國廣播中說:「無現金社會是我們的理想。的確,100% 無現金的社會難以實現,但我們可以從少現金社會開始,那麼無現金社會也就不再遙不可及。」莫迪也呼籲印度年輕人,每天向十個家庭推廣他們如何透過行動 app、行動銀行、現金卡或信用卡進行無現金交易。


“The timing is also odd. India has recently introduced a system that makes it easy for anybody to make or receive payments from their mobile phone, whether they be businesses or individuals. But the Unified Payments Interface, as it is known, is still in the early stages of implementation, so cannot really help overcome the current cash-crunch.” –The Economist

經濟學人認為,此政策推出的時機怪異,印度近期推出的系統(統一支付介面 Unified Payments Interface)讓企業、個人都能透過手機收、付款,但系統仍處於早期實施階段,無法有效協助處理現金不足的問題。

“It's long been a dream of a certain type, that cashless society. If all transactions are electronic then all transactions can be chased, can be recorded, checked. And thus it will be possible to monitor what everyone is doing, in detail. That's not a power I would want to offer the State….”—Tim Worstall, Fellow at Adams Smiths Institute, Forbes

英國 Adam Smiths 研究員 Time Worstall 在富比世的專欄中說:「無現金社會長久以來都是一種理想。但交易完全電子化,代表所有交易都可以被追蹤、紀錄、檢查,每個人交易行為皆有可能被全面監控。我不會想讓國家擁有這樣的權力……。」

“Sweden is beginning to look at doing away with physical money in favor of a completely digital currency given that the amount of hard cash and coin in circulation has already decreased by 40 percent (in 7 years).” “This abandonment is due to several factors, among these is the prevalence of cards, both debit and credit. According to the Riksbank, Sweden’s Central Bank, the number of cash withdrawals are steadily decreasing while the number of credit card transactions are increasing.” –

Sweden’s strong IT infrastructure which leads to more adoption of payment apps like Swish and the digitization of some Swedish Banks.

「鑒於紙鈔和硬幣的流通(在七年間)已下降了 40%,瑞典開始考慮廢除現金,讓貨幣全面電子化。」科技新聞網站 報導,現金卡和信用卡的廣泛使用是政府考慮廢除的眾多原因之一,根據瑞典中央銀行 Riskbank 表示,現金提款頻率穩定下降,而信用卡交易頻率則在提升中。瑞典強大的資訊科技基礎建設讓民眾易於採用行動支付 app 如 Swishand,同時幫助了部分瑞典銀行的數位化。


1. Appeal to 呼籲
The citizens appealed to their mayor to try to find a solution to the housing crisis.

2. Doing away with 廢除
The government did away with free school meals.

Do I have to do away with my habit?

3. Prevalence 普及;流行
Fewer people choose cable TV with the prevalence of streaming TV.

資料來源:The Economist, The Economic Times,,